|
Post by Wave57 on Sept 12, 2011 21:23:08 GMT -5
Remember my post-by-post analysis D1?
That is what I'm talking about.
|
|
|
Post by musicalmafia on Sept 12, 2011 21:30:00 GMT -5
Remember my post-by-post analysis D1? That is what I'm talking about. Meh. That isn't really metagaming just you being strange.
|
|
|
Post by Wave57 on Sept 12, 2011 21:30:40 GMT -5
But my read on Joe was very good.
Not on Soupy though.
|
|
|
Post by robbiecon on Sept 13, 2011 9:28:42 GMT -5
Answers to the quiz:
1. How many songs do I have in my library? (Closest gets the point, if both within 100 you both get a point) 1218 is the correct answer, you both had the answer 1107 iirc, i just don't have all my songs on my DLC quickplay, I guess that's the problem there. So both wrong.
2. What genre do I have the most songs from? MM said Rock, JR48fan said Metal. Rock is my second highest tally, and Metal is 4th highest I believe.
I'm surprised you didn't get the actual answer, which is Classic Rock.
3. What genres do I have ALL songs from? The two answers I was looking for here were Southern Rock, and Blues. JR answered Classic Rock here! But MM got this very much correct when he named Blues, so he got the points. He also told me some other ones I have all the songs from. These include Classical, Reggae/Ska, R&B/Soul/Funk, Pop/Dance/Electronic. So a deserved winner of this question.
4. What is the most recent album I bought? I think this may have been interpreted incorrectly, as both had the answer Dr. Feelgood (which I did admittedly purchase recently). In terms of what is the album I last bought, the correct answer is Axis:Bold As Love. In terms of what is actually the most recently released in terms of the actual year, the answer would be Tragic Kingdom by No Doubt.
5. What is the last week of DLC where I have bought nothing? (please give the artists names, not the date) Both got this one right, the answer was Incubus.
|
|
|
Post by JesusSilencio on Sept 13, 2011 11:49:29 GMT -5
Things like this really make me question if the town is actually "good." Lynches are very brutal and unjustified. Is the town filled with white people from the Jim Crowe South? Seriously. Just gruesome. Town definitely isn't always good. I've played in/modded a few games where the Mafia were the "good" guys (LOTRII and Manipulator on MTGS, M&L: PiT on DEM, Werewolf on TWC). The town is simply the majority. I still would've enjoyed this more if people didn't jump to conclusions early. Gary, you were right, but guess what? Names don't equal Town. However, it does equal something called metagaming. But the thing that annoyed me most was when people jumped on me just because I said I had a similar role to Janitor. C'mon guys, I know you're all better than that. As has been said by a bunch of people, gaming the mod isn't always bad. The only time I've ever seen a janitor role on town was that one game here (RBO mafia), and honestly, it was a pretty dumb idea anyway. It does depend on the mod though: for example, in games that I host I typically take some effort to make it difficult to guess people's alignments simply based on their roles/rolenames or the setup. Some mods are especially tricky, so you do have to be careful. In general, lynching solely based on roles/rolenames is almost always a bad idea, but from what little I read of this game, you were acting a bit scummy. ~ On Milk's role: I had the exact same role in Rush Mafia, and I don't think it's especially broken (I assume that Milk loses his ability once he's the last townie). It is powerful though, and I don't think I would recommend anyone putting it in any future games; something like a traditional Ghost or a Stump is probably more fair. I'm surprised you guys tried to lynch him though; that's not the type of claim mafia would make up. ~ What was the setup of this game again?
|
|
|
Post by robbiecon on Sept 13, 2011 12:10:34 GMT -5
The set-up was 11 townies, 1 neutral, 3 mafia. I'll post the role PM's later on.
As for Milk's role, the mafia could have won assuming they had Town -1 numbers. (so 1 mafia left could have won with Milk and anyone else being alive). Same goes for SK.
I probably should have not gone quite for one from each game as scum, that's the advantage of the sequel, DLC covers a vast range of songs, so anything is possible.
Dead talking I think helped the game stay active, sometimes things can get stagnant here when people are killed off. I know the mafia weren't pleased by it, but it's done on many other sites, so why not here.
|
|
|
Post by JesusSilencio on Sept 13, 2011 13:07:39 GMT -5
Oh yeah, the dead talking.
I'm not a fan of it in general, but if you do it, you have to limit the number of info roles the town has, and personally, I believe that the mafia should have some way of shutting up some townies for good. Like, it feels weird to have both janitors and dead talking; I know that people aren't supposed to talk about their role when they're dead, but if you have information that points to someone being scum/town, it's hard to hide or not use it.
|
|
|
Post by SMAP on Sept 19, 2011 19:23:08 GMT -5
and why is this up here as well
|
|